Is Choosing to Be Childfree A Selfish Decision?

The choice to live without children, often called being childfree, is sparking heated debates everywhere. In Indonesia, this topic took center stage when influencer Gita Savitri unapologetically shared her decision to forgo motherhood. Her bold stance triggered a whirlwind of reactions—some applauding her courage, others fiercely criticizing her. But what’s really driving this growing trend? Is it pure independence, societal pressure, or something else entirely? And here’s the big question: is being childfree truly a selfish act, or could it be a thoughtful choice with deeper meaning? Stick around as we uncover the surprising truths behind this polarizing issue!

Why People Choose To Be Childfree?

At its core, being childfree refers to the conscious decision made by individuals or couples to forgo parenthood, whether biologically or through adoption. This is distinct from being childless, which describes a situation where someone desires children but is unable to have them due to biological limitations. The childfree choice is a deliberate one, made even when financial or health circumstances would allow for parenting. According to Tunggono (2021), the decision to remain childfree is often rooted in a variety of reasons that reflect a deep contemplation of the significant responsibilities that come with being a parent. Here are some of the key motivations behind this choice:  

• Economic Factors 

The soaring costs of raising a child—from childbirth to education—make many people pause and reconsider the idea of parenthood. It's no surprise that the financial burden can be daunting! Many individuals find themselves weighing the expenses of diapers, daycare, and college tuition against their own dreams and aspirations. Moreover, a growing number of people are choosing to invest their resources in their careers or personal lives rather than in raising children.

• Past Trauma

Negative experiences with parenting or family conflicts can leave deep scars, making some individuals feel unprepared to start their own families. The fear of repeating the same patterns or subjecting their children to similar hardships can be overwhelming. For many, the thought of becoming a parent brings back memories of their own childhood struggles, leading to a profound concern that they might inadvertently pass on trauma or dysfunction. This reflection often leads to the decision to remain childfree, as they prioritize emotional well-being and the desire to break the cycle of pain.  

• Deteriorating World Conditions 

Concerns about the environment and the state of the planet weigh heavily on the minds of those contemplating parenthood. Will their children inherit a world plagued by crises? This uncertainty can lead to a profound sense of responsibility, prompting some to choose a childfree lifestyle as a way to avoid contributing to the problems facing future generations.

• Social Pressure 

For some, choosing a childfree lifestyle is a bold statement against traditional norms that view marriage and parenthood as life’s primary obligations. In a society that often equates personal worth with family status, opting out of having children can feel like an act of rebellion. This decision allows individuals to challenge the status quo and redefine what fulfillment looks like. By embracing a childfree life, they are not just rejecting societal expectations; they are also carving out space for alternative paths that prioritize personal happiness, career ambitions, and self-discovery.  

• Mental and Physical Health

The journey to parenthood can be overwhelming, and for those grappling with mental health challenges or specific medical conditions, the thought of raising a child may feel daunting or even unmanageable. The pressure to be a "perfect" parent can exacerbate existing issues, leading some to prioritize their well-being over societal expectations. By opting out of parenthood, they can focus on their health, personal growth, and self-care without the added stress of raising children.

While the reasons for choosing a childfree lifestyle are valid and deeply personal, this decision often faces criticism from society. Many view it as a selfish act, suggesting that individuals are prioritizing their own comfort over social responsibility. In Indonesia, where social and cultural norms hold significant sway, the choice to remain childfree can clash with prevailing beliefs, such as the adage "Banyak anak, banyak rezeki." This perspective places immense pressure on individuals to conform to traditional expectations of parenthood, making the decision to forgo children feel even more controversial. 

Pros and Cons of the Childfree Decision

According to Jenuri et al. (2022), the community supporting the childfree lifestyle highlights several positive impacts of this choice: Population Control Choosing a childfree lifestyle helps control population growth, reducing pressure on natural resources and pollution. It promotes a sustainable future. For those wanting to nurture children, adoption from orphanages provides a loving alternative without contributing to population growth.

• Reducing Burdens on Children 

Opting for a childfree lifestyle can significantly minimize the burdens often placed on children, such as financial support and the responsibility of caring for aging parents. The underlying belief is that children should not have to bear heavy responsibilities simply because they did not choose to be born. By choosing not to have children, individuals can break the cycle of expectation that often leads to children feeling obligated to support their parents or manage family affairs. This choice promotes a healthier dynamic, allowing future generations to pursue their own paths without the weight of undue responsibility. 

• Economic Stability

Choosing a childfree lifestyle can alleviate financial burdens and reduce the risk of poverty associated with raising children. Without the costs of child-rearing, individuals can allocate resources more effectively, leading to greater savings and opportunities for personal growth. This financial freedom allows for a more comfortable lifestyle filled with enriching experiences.

Although it has positive impacts, people also view being childfree as something negative, including: Cultural and Religious Norms Rejection From a female perspective, the decision to remain childfree can carry significant negative implications, particularly in relation to cultural and religious norms. In many societies, having children is viewed as a blessing and a fundamental aspect of life. Women who choose to be childfree may face societal backlash, as their choice is often interpreted as a rejection of these deeply held beliefs. 

• Diminishing Opportunities for Others

The choice to remain childfree is viewed by some as an act that disregards the struggles of families who desperately wish to have children but are unable to do so. This perception can create social tension and evoke feelings of injustice among certain groups (Ramadhani & Tsabitah, 2022).  

• Disconnection with Culture

According to Karana (2023), women who choose to be childfree are more likely to develop negative attitudes toward cultural norms. They may feel disconnected from cultural values, particularly those that emphasize pronatalist ideology, which promotes procreation as a social norm.

• Becoming a Shortage in Certain Countries 

The childfree trend is lowering birth rates globally, leading to population shortages. For instance, Japan's births dropped nearly 6% in early 2024 compared to 2023, with only 350,074 births. This decline reduces young workers, strains healthcare and pensions, and hampers economic growth and elderly care.  

Conclusion 

In conclusion, the decision to be childfree is a complex and deeply personal choice. Choosing to be childfree does not inherently reflect selfishness but rather an awareness of the responsibilities and challenges of parenting. The increasing prevalence of this lifestyle in Indonesia, as reflected by public figures and data trends, calls for a more nuanced understanding and acceptance of diverse life choices. With this, we hope that there will be more discussions and research in the future regarding parenting, particularly about mental, physical, and financial readiness before having children. We also hope that in the future, there will be policies that support families with children, so that people will feel less apprehensive about having children.

References 

Audinovic, V., & Nugroho, R. S. (2023). Persepsi childfree di kalangan generasi Zilenial Jawa Timur. Jurnal Keluarga Berencana, 8(1), 1-11. 

Dita, D., Takdir, T., & Rahmawati, R. (2024). CHILDFREE IN THE PERSPECTIVE OF ISLAMIC LAW (CHILDFREE DALAM PERSPEKTIF HUKUM ISLAM). JURNAL ILMIAH ADVOKASI, 12(3), 367-381. 

Lastika, I. A., Ayuningtias, A. U. H., & Dewi, N. N. A. I. (2024). Fenomena Childfree Dalam Perspektif Generasi Z. JURNAL KESEHATAN, SAINS, DAN TEKNOLOGI (JAKASAKTI), 3(2), 145-155. 

Rizka, S. M., Yeniningsih, T. K., Mutmainnah, M., & Yuhasriati, Y. (2021). Childfree Phenomenon in Indonesia. Proceedings of AICS-Social Sciences, 11, 336-341.

Nashiroh, T. S. A., & Firmonasari, A. (2024). Stigmatisasi terhadap individu childfree dalam komentar Youtube: analisis wacana kritis. Diglosia: Jurnal Kajian Bahasa, Sastra, dan Pengajarannya, 7(2), 237-246. 

Sodah, Y., & Korompis, P. A. (2024). Childfree Sebagai Pilihan Hidup dalam Perkawinan. Jurnal Pendidikan Indonesia, 5(11). 

Zakiyyah, E., & Mursalin, H. (2023). Fenomena Childfree dalam Perspektif Islam. Mauriduna: Journal of Islamic Studies, 4(2), 192-203. 

Handayani, T. (2024). The Impact of Childfree on Health and Economic. International Journal of Science and Human Research, 7(07), 5071- 5075. 

Firdaus, M. R., Agniawati, N. G., & Solahudin, M. (2021, May). Johan Galtung's Theory of Violence and Conflict: A Study of Pela Gandong's Local Wisdom as a Media for Conflict Resolution in Ambon. In Gunung Djati Conference Series (Vol. 4, pp. 831-848). 

Pangestu, F. N. N., & Jenuri, J. (2023). Fenomena Childfree Pada Keluarga Milenial Dalam Pandangan Islam: Kontroversi Atau Solusi? Tahdzib Al-Akhlaq: Jurnal Pendidikan Islam, 6(2), 323-330.

Ramadhani, K. W., & Tsabitah, D. (2022). Fenomena Childfree dan Prinsip Idealisme Keluarga Indonesia dalam Perspektif Mahasiswa. LoroNG: Media Pengkajian Sosial Budaya, 11(1), 17-29. 

Tunggono, V. (2021). Childfree and Happy, ed. Rifai Asyhari.(Yogyakarta: Buku Mojok Group. 

Leliana, I., Suryani, I., Haikal, A., & Septian, R. (2020). Respon Masyarakat Mengenai Fenomena “Childfree” (Studi Kasus influencer Gita Savitri). 23(1), 36–43.