The Five Stages of Research-Based Teaching: A Comprehensive Overview (Best Practice)

The Five Stages of Research-Based Teaching: A Comprehensive Overview

Research-based teaching is an approach to teaching and learning that involves the systematic use of research evidence to inform teaching practices. This approach consists of five stages: Formulating Problems, Gathering Information, Analyzing Data - Information, Making Conclusions, and Reporting. Each of these stages involves specific roles and responsibilities for both teachers and students, as well as the development of knowledge and skills necessary for effective research-based teaching. In this article, we provide a comprehensive overview of these five stages and explore how they can be implemented in the classroom to improve student learning outcomes.

A. The Five Stages of Research-Based Teaching

Research-based teaching is an instructional approach that integrates scientific inquiry into the classroom. It involves a systematic process that includes five major stages: Formulating Problems, Gathering Information, Analyzing Data-Information, Making Conclusions, and Reporting. Each stage has specific roles for teachers and students and requires certain knowledge and skills.

1. Formulating Problems

Formulating Problems is the first and crucial stage in the research-based teaching process. It is a step that involves identifying an issue, topic, or question that students will explore through scientific inquiry. In this stage, teachers play a crucial role in guiding students in formulating open-ended questions that foster critical thinking, encourage curiosity, and enable students to develop their problem-solving skills.

Baca juga: The Art of Teaching Analytical Thinking: 10 Key Training Points

To start with, teachers work with students to identify a topic or issue that is relevant, engaging, and aligned with curriculum standards. Once a topic is selected, the teacher encourages students to brainstorm questions related to the topic that could guide their inquiry. The teacher should help students develop questions that are clear, precise, and specific, to enable them to focus on their research inquiry.

To make the questions open-ended and encourage critical thinking, teachers should guide students in formulating questions that do not have a fixed answer, but rather allow for multiple perspectives and interpretations. Open-ended questions enable students to think creatively, challenge assumptions, and develop their problem-solving skills. For instance, a teacher can help students to rephrase a closed-ended question such as "What are the colors of the rainbow?" to an open-ended one such as "How do rainbows form, and what factors determine the colors they display?"

Furthermore, teachers should guide students in developing hypotheses and setting objectives. Hypotheses are statements that explain the relationship between variables in a research question, while objectives are specific outcomes that students hope to achieve by the end of the inquiry. By formulating hypotheses and setting objectives, students are motivated and focused on their research inquiry, and they can apply critical thinking skills to test their hypotheses.

Finally, the student's role in this stage is to develop questions and hypotheses that are based on prior knowledge and research. Students are expected to use their prior knowledge, experience, and observations to develop questions and hypotheses that will guide their inquiry. They should also conduct preliminary research to understand the background information on the topic and identify gaps in their understanding that they need to address.

2. Gathering Information

The second stage in research-based teaching is Gathering Information. This stage involves collecting data and information that is relevant to the research question or problem that was formulated in the previous stage. The teacher's role in this stage is to provide guidance and support to help students select appropriate research methods and sources of information, while the students' role is to gather and record data accurately.

Baca juga: Dengan Visi Pendidikan Ki Hajar Dewantara, Kita Bergerak Bersama Semarakkan Merdeka Belajar (Artikel dalam Rangka Hardiknas 2023)

To start with, the teacher helps students identify sources of information such as primary and secondary sources that are relevant to their research question. Primary sources include data or information that is collected firsthand, while secondary sources refer to information that is collected by others and published in books, articles, or other forms of media. The teacher should guide students on how to differentiate between primary and secondary sources and the importance of using reliable and credible sources in their research inquiry.

Baca juga: Journaling as a Preventive Method for Handling Troubled Students in Schools

In addition, teachers should guide students in selecting appropriate research methods to gather data. Research methods may include observations, surveys, experiments, and interviews, among others. The teacher should help students understand the strengths and limitations of each research method and guide them in selecting the most appropriate method for their research question.

Moreover, teachers should teach students how to collect, record, and organize data accurately. They should emphasize the importance of maintaining accuracy and consistency in data collection and recording to ensure the validity and reliability of their findings. Teachers should also guide students on how to analyze and interpret data to draw meaningful conclusions.

Finally, the student's role in this stage is to select appropriate research methods and collect and record data accurately. They should also organize data in a manner that makes it easy to analyze and interpret. Students should maintain detailed records of their data collection process to enable them to trace their steps and provide evidence of their findings.

3. Analyzing Data - Information

The third stage in research-based teaching is Analyzing Data-Information. This stage involves analyzing and interpreting the data and information collected in the previous stage. The teacher's role in this stage is to provide guidance and feedback on data analysis techniques, while the students' role is to analyze and interpret data accurately and make connections between data and information.

To start with, teachers should help students develop skills in data analysis, including organizing, comparing, and contrasting data. They should guide students on how to use various tools such as charts, graphs, and tables to organize and present data visually. This helps students to see patterns and relationships in the data and make informed conclusions.

Furthermore, teachers should guide students in identifying patterns and relationships in data and information. They should help students to look for similarities and differences in the data and identify any patterns or trends that may emerge. Students should also learn how to identify outliers and anomalies in data and explain their significance in the research inquiry.

Moreover, teachers should encourage students to make connections between data and information. They should guide students in synthesizing and integrating the data and information to form a comprehensive understanding of the research question or problem. This involves critical thinking and requires students to draw conclusions and make predictions based on the data they have analyzed.

Finally, the students' role in this stage is to analyze and interpret data accurately and make connections between data and information. They should also communicate their findings clearly and concisely. This involves developing skills in presenting data and information in a way that is easy to understand and meaningful to the audience.

4. Making Conclusions

The fourth stage in research-based teaching is Making Conclusions. This stage involves drawing conclusions and making inferences based on the data and information analyzed in the previous stage. The teacher's role is to provide guidance and feedback on making conclusions and inferences, while the students' role is to draw conclusions and make inferences based on the data and information analyzed.

To begin with, teachers should help students identify patterns and trends in the data and make connections to the research question. They should guide students on how to interpret and analyze the data to draw meaningful conclusions. Students should be able to recognize any significant patterns or trends that emerge in the data, and relate them back to the research question. This helps students to build a clear understanding of the research topic and develop informed conclusions.

Furthermore, teachers should guide students in making inferences based on the data and information. Inferences are conclusions based on evidence and reasoning, and this involves critical thinking. Teachers should encourage students to make reasonable inferences from the data they have analyzed and consider multiple perspectives to reach a conclusion. They should also help students to evaluate the reliability and validity of the data and information used to draw conclusions.

Moreover, the teacher's role is to provide guidance and feedback on making conclusions and inferences. They should ensure that students understand the criteria used to draw conclusions and make inferences. Teachers should also ensure that students are aware of the limitations of the data and information they used to draw conclusions.

Finally, the students' role in this stage is to draw conclusions and make inferences based on the data and information analyzed. They should present their conclusions and inferences in a clear and organized manner, highlighting the evidence and reasoning that led to their conclusions. Students should also reflect on the implications of their conclusions and consider how their findings relate to real-world situations.

5. Reporting

The final stage in research-based teaching is Reporting. This stage involves communicating the research findings to others. The teacher's role is to provide guidance and feedback on effective communication, while the students' role is to communicate their research findings effectively.

To begin with, teachers should help students develop skills in presenting their research findings through various formats, such as written reports, oral presentations, or multimedia presentations. Teachers should guide students on how to organize their research findings and present them in a clear and coherent manner. They should also provide guidance on selecting appropriate communication formats for their target audience and purpose.

Furthermore, teachers should guide students in evaluating the effectiveness of their communication. They should provide feedback on the clarity, coherence, and effectiveness of the communication, and help students identify areas for improvement. This helps students to refine their communication skills and effectively present their research findings to different audiences.

Moreover, the teacher's role is to provide guidance and feedback on effective communication. They should ensure that students understand the purpose and objectives of their communication, and that they are communicating their research findings in a way that is clear, concise, and engaging. Teachers should also encourage students to use evidence-based arguments and communicate their ideas effectively.

Finally, the students' role in this stage is to communicate their research findings effectively. They should present their research findings in a clear and organized manner, highlighting the evidence and reasoning that led to their conclusions. Students should also consider their target audience and purpose and select appropriate communication formats to effectively convey their findings. They should use evidence-based arguments and communicate their ideas effectively.

B. Research-Based School Movement

According to Michael Fullan (2007), a well-known educational change expert, there are several things that need to be in place for research-based teaching by individual teachers to evolve into a research-based school movement. These are: Leadership, Collaborative Culture, Data-driven Decision-Making, Professional Learning, and Student-Centered Approach.

1. Leadership

It emphasizes the importance of strong leadership in promoting research-based teaching and creating a culture of continuous learning and improvement in schools. Effective leaders provide a clear vision for the school and create an environment that encourages research-based teaching by providing necessary resources and support to teachers. For instance:

• A principal who values research-based teaching may set up a professional development program that focuses on building teachers' knowledge and skills in research-based teaching.
• The principal may also provide resources such as funding for research projects, access to data analysis tools, and technology resources to support research-based teaching.
• A principal may prioritize research-based teaching in the school's strategic plan and set goals for teachers to engage in research-based practices and monitor progress towards these goals.
• The principal may create a culture of continuous learning and improvement by encouraging teachers to share their experiences and knowledge through collaborative teams, meetings, and conferences.

In summary, leadership plays a critical role in promoting research-based teaching, and effective leaders provide a clear vision, necessary resources, and support to teachers.

2. Collaborative Culture

It emphasizes the importance of a collaborative culture in promoting research-based teaching. Teachers should work together to share their experiences, knowledge, and best practices in research-based teaching. Collaboration helps to create a culture of trust and shared responsibility for student learning by promoting peer learning, problem-solving, and innovation. For instance:

• Teachers may form research teams to explore specific research questions, collect data, and analyze results collaboratively. This provides opportunities for teachers to share their expertise and learn from each other's experiences.
• Collaborative work also involves sharing lesson plans, instructional strategies, and assessment methods that align with research-based practices. This sharing helps to enhance the effectiveness of research-based teaching and promote the adoption of best practices.
• Teachers may also participate in professional learning communities to discuss research-based teaching and share their experiences. Such communities create opportunities for teachers to engage in reflective practice, receive feedback on their teaching, and collaborate on projects.

In summary, a collaborative culture is essential for promoting research-based teaching, and it provides opportunities for teachers to share their expertise, learn from each other, and improve their teaching practices.

3. Data-driven Decision-Making

Data-driven decision-making is a crucial component of research-based teaching, as it allows schools to evaluate their effectiveness and make evidence-based decisions. Teachers and school leaders should be trained on how to collect, analyze and interpret data. By using data to inform their decision-making, schools can identify areas where students are struggling and adjust teaching practices accordingly. For example, if data analysis shows that students are struggling with a particular topic, the teacher can change the teaching strategy to better address the issue. Additionally, data can be used to set goals for student achievement and track progress towards those goals. For instance, if a school sets a goal of increasing the percentage of students who meet proficiency standards in reading, they can track progress by analyzing student data on a regular basis. By regularly analyzing data, schools can make informed decisions and continuously improve their teaching practices. 

4. Professional Learning

It emphasizes the importance of continuous professional learning for teachers to improve their skills and knowledge related to research-based teaching. It suggests that schools should provide opportunities for teachers to engage in various forms of professional learning, such as attending workshops and conferences, conducting action research, and participating in peer observation and coaching.

To simplify, professional learning refers to the process of improving a teacher's knowledge and skills through various learning opportunities, such as training sessions, workshops, and conferences. It helps teachers stay updated with the latest research and teaching strategies and allows them to apply these strategies effectively in their classrooms.

For example, a school can provide a workshop on how to develop research questions and analyze data for teachers who are new to research-based teaching. The workshop can be led by an expert in the field, who can provide hands-on training to the teachers. Similarly, a group of teachers can collaborate on an action research project, where they conduct research on a particular topic and implement changes based on the findings. The teachers can learn from each other and share their experiences, which can further enhance their knowledge and skills.

5. Student-Centered Approach

A student-centered approach to research-based teaching is focused on meeting the unique needs of each student. This involves understanding their individual strengths, challenges, and learning styles. Teachers must use this knowledge to design teaching practices that are tailored to the specific needs of their students. For example, a teacher who recognizes that a student is a visual learner may use more visual aids in their instruction, such as diagrams, videos, or graphic organizers.

Teachers also need to use a variety of teaching strategies that are based on research evidence and are appropriate for the needs of their students. This can include inquiry-based learning, project-based learning, and problem-based learning, among others. These strategies are designed to engage students and encourage critical thinking, collaboration, and problem-solving skills.

Ultimately, a student-centered approach requires that teachers focus on the learning outcomes of their students, rather than simply delivering content. They need to assess student progress regularly and adjust their teaching practices accordingly to ensure that all students are achieving their full potential. For example, if a teacher notices that a group of students is struggling with a particular concept, they may adjust their teaching methods to provide additional support and guidance.

C. To What Extent Do You Have a Research-Based Teaching Paradigm?

We would like to invite you to participate in a self-evaluation activity using a Likert scale checklist. This activity aims to help you assess the extent to which you already have a research-based teaching paradigm in your teaching practices. The checklist consists of 15 items that are divided into five categories: Formulating Problems, Gathering Information, Analyzing Data - Information, Making Conclusions, and Reporting. Each item has a choice of 1=strongly disagree, 2=disagree, 3=neutral, 4=agree, and 5=strongly agree.

By completing this checklist, you will have a better understanding of your current level of research-based teaching and identify areas that you may need to improve. We encourage you to answer each item honestly and to the best of your knowledge and ability. After completing the checklist, you can find out your score and interpretation to understand your level of research-based teaching better.

We appreciate your participation and hope that this activity will be helpful in your teaching journey.

Formulating Problems

I am able to identify problems that affect student learning. (1 2 3 4 5)

I can develop research questions related to student learning. (1 2 3 4 5)

I can design research projects to investigate student learning problems. (1 2 3 4 5)

Gathering Information

I can locate and use relevant literature related to my research questions. (1 2 3 4 5)

I can use various sources of data to gather information (e.g. surveys, observations, interviews). (1 2 3 4 5)

I can analyze data to gain insight into student learning problems. (1 2 3 4 5)

Analyzing Data - Information

I am able to use appropriate methods to analyze data. (1 2 3 4 5)

I am able to interpret the results of data analysis. (1 2 3 4 5)

I can identify patterns and trends in data. (1 2 3 4 5)

Making Conclusions

I am able to draw meaningful conclusions from my research. (1 2 3 4 5)

I can apply my research findings to improve my teaching practices. (1 2 3 4 5)

I can communicate my research findings to others. (1 2 3 4 5)

Reporting

I am able to present my research findings effectively (e.g. written reports, oral presentations, multimedia presentations). (1 2 3 4 5)

I can evaluate the effectiveness of my communication. (1 2 3 4 5)

I can use feedback to improve my communication skills. (1 2 3 4 5)

To evaluate themselves, the respondent can rate each item on a scale of 1 to 5, with 1 being "strongly disagree" and 5 being "strongly agree." Once they have rated themselves on each item, they can add up their scores to get a total score out of 75 (5 points for each item).

To interpret their score, they can use the following guidelines:

55-75: Highly skilled in research-based teaching practices

40-54: Moderately skilled in research-based teaching practices

25-39: Somewhat skilled in research-based teaching practices

10-24: Not skilled in research-based teaching practices

Of course, it's important to note that a Likert scale is just one tool for self-evaluation and should be used in conjunction with other forms of reflection and feedback.

In conclusion, research-based teaching is a powerful approach to teaching and learning that can improve student outcomes and create a culture of continuous learning and improvement. The five stages of research-based teaching, which include formulating problems, gathering information, analyzing data-information, making conclusions, and reporting, provide a framework for teachers to engage in research-based teaching and for students to develop important knowledge and skills. By following these stages and incorporating the key elements of strong leadership, a collaborative culture, data-driven decision-making, ongoing professional learning, and a student-centered approach, schools can build a research-based teaching movement that supports student success and improves the overall quality of education.

References

Fullan, M. (2007). The new meaning of educational change (4th ed.). Teachers College Press.

Hattie, J. (2009). Visible learning: A synthesis of over 800 meta-analyses relating to achievement. Routledge.