Peter Parker's Heroic Evolution : A comparative analysis of Peter Parker's Character Development in the film adaptations of Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004) and Spider-Man 3 (2007).
Kevin Georgy Kilen
Universitas Bangka Belitung, Pangkal Pinang, Kep. Bangka Belitung.
Fakultas Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik
Email : kevingeorgy7@gmail.com
Abstract.
The research delves into the multifaceted character development of Peter Parker, widely known as Spider-Man, as portrayed in the film adaptations of Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004), and Spider-Man 3 (2007). Employing a comparative analysis, the study scrutinizes the unique storytelling approaches across the trilogy, shedding light on the evolution of Peter Parker's heroic journey. The research adopts a Descriptive Qualitative Approach, recognizing the complex and subjective nature of character and narrative storytelling in these films. Through qualitative methods, the study explores the dynamic character of Peter Parker, emphasizing gradual change, internal conflict, and moral evolution. The results and discussions reveal a compelling evolution of Peter Parker's character arc, portraying his transformation from a timid high school student to a confident superhero. Drawing parallels to Joseph Campbell's hero's journey, the films capture essential elements, including the call of adventure, trials, moral dilemmas, and transformation. Internal catalysts, such as Uncle Ben's death, and external catalysts, like formidable villains and the black suit, play pivotal roles in shaping Peter Parker's journey. The hero's dilemma, a recurrent theme, adds depth to his character, illustrating the challenges of balancing ordinary life with superhero responsibilities. Contributing significantly to Spider-Man's enduring popularity is the relatability of Peter Parker as the quintessential "everyman." The films emphasize his personal struggles, making him a character with whom audiences can connect on a personal level. Scenes depicting universal desires for change and empowerment enhance this relatability. The moral complexity portrayed, especially in Spider-Man 3, underscores the human side of superheroes, showcasing that even heroes have flaws and grapple with ethical dilemmas.
The conclusion of this research provides invaluable insights into the captivating evolution of Spider-Man, contributing to a deeper understanding of his enduring appeal. By dissecting the character's development in cinematic adaptations, the study highlights the symbiotic relationship between relatable character development, moral growth, and storytelling, solidifying Spider-Man's position as a beloved and timeless superhero in the world of comics and cinema.
Keywords : Â Peter Parker, Spider-Man, Character Development, Comparative Analysis, Film Adaptations, Heroic Journey.
1. Introduction.
Peter Parker, famously known as Spider-Man, has held a cherished place in the superhero pantheon for several decades. The transformation from a timid and nerdy high school student to a courageous and responsible hero has captivated global audiences. The thesis aims to delve into the intricacies of Peter Parker's character development as portrayed in the film adaptations of Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004), and Spider- Man 3 (2007). The research employs Spider-Man as a unique lens to scrutinize the evolution of this iconic character. It offers a profound understanding of the multifaceted interplay between his personal struggles, moral dilemmas, and his growth as a superhero. The comparative analysis conducted in this study seeks to elucidate the diverse storytelling approaches employed in these cinematic renditions and how they contributed to Peter Parker's heroic evolution. Ultimately, this study enriches our comprehension of Spider-Man's enduring appeal in popular culture. Spider-Man, introduced in the Marvel comic books in the early 1960s, quickly became a cultural phenomenon. His alter ego, Peter Parker, embodies the quintessential "everyman" who must grapple with ordinary life challenges while shouldering the responsibilities of a superhero. This dichotomy has been a central theme in the Spider-Man narrative and is vividly brought to life in the film adaptations of the early 2000s. Peter Parker's character arc across the three films is emblematic of the hero's journey. Beginning as a socially anxious and academically gifted high school student in "Spider-Man," his transformation into the self-assured Spider-Man is a compelling study in character development. The thesis dissects the evolution of Peter Parker's character, paying particular attention to the internal and external forces that shape him. Key themes such as personal loss, moral responsibility, and the consequences of choices are examined to reveal the intricacies of his growth.
The comparative analysis employed in this research investigates the nuanced differences in storytelling and character portrayal in each film. The diverse directorial approaches, screenplay adaptations, and thematic emphases across the trilogy are scrutinized to illuminate the distinct paths taken in shaping Peter Parker's journey. By contrasting the narrative choices and character developments in "Spider-Man," "Spider- Man 2," and "Spider-Man 3," this study highlights the evolution of Peter Parker's heroism, delving into the impact of each film's narrative style and directorial vision. The purpose of this research is to contribute a deeper understanding of Spider-Man's enduring popularity in popular culture. By dissecting the heroic evolution of Peter Parker in these cinematic adaptations, it sheds light on why this character resonates with audiences across generations. The research underscores the significance of relatable character development and moral growth in superhero narratives, as well as the role of cinema in shaping the iconic figure of Spider-Man. The analysis of Peter Parker's character development in "Spider-Man," "Spider-Man 2," and "Spider-Man 3" offers valuable insights into the enduring appeal of this beloved character. The comparative examination of these films illuminates the intricacies of storytelling and character evolution, ultimately contributing to a more comprehensive understanding of Spider-Man's significance in the realm of popular culture.
2. Methodology.
The research methodology used in "Comparative Analysis of Peter Parker's Character Development in the Film Adaptations of Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004), and Spider-Man 3 (2007)" is based on a Qualitative Descriptive Approach. , were strategically chosen to facilitate a nuanced exploration of the complex and subjective nature of the characters and narrative storytelling in the selected films. This approach is in line with several related theories that contribute to a deeper analysis of Peter Parker's character development.
The theoretical framework underlying qualitative methodology is story and narrative theory. Story and narrative theory was adopted by Roland Barthes, whose aim was to provide a basis for understanding the structure and elements of storytelling. Using this theory, the research methodology recognizes the narrative complexity inherent in the selected Spider-Man films and emphasizes the importance of dissecting the storytelling techniques used to depict the evolution of Peter Parker's character.Analysis of character development in a film can involve a number of methodological steps to explore in depth how the characters develop throughout the narrative. Analysis of character development in a film can involve a number of methodological steps to explore in depth how the characters develop throughout the narrative.
a. Identify the Main Character.
Determine the main characters to be analyzed. Focus on characters who experience significant development during the film.
b. Initial Character Description.
Character analysis begins with understanding the initial state of the character. How is the character introduced, what are his motivations, and how is his personality explained at the start of the film?
c. Analysis of Actions and Decisions.
Review the actions and decisions taken by the characters throughout the film. How do these decisions reflect changes in the character? Was there a particular event that triggered the change?
d. Reaction to Conflict.
Observe how characters respond to conflict or challenges. Is there an emotional or mental evolution in the way the characters respond to stress or dramatic events?
e. Changes in Relationships with Other Characters.
Watch how the character's relationships with other characters develop. Has there been a change in interpersonal dynamics? How do interactions with other characters affect that character's development?
f. Analysis of Emotional and Psychological Changes.
Review the character's emotional and psychological changes. How do the characters' feelings, values, or beliefs change throughout the film?
g. Importance of Key Events.
Identify key events that play an important role in character development. Analyze how these events shaped the character and steered him in a particular direction.
h. Analyze Dialogue and Physical Actions.
Pay attention to the way the characters speak and move. Are there any changes in the way the characters communicate or express themselves?
i. Conclusion and Evaluation.
Recapitulate character development and evaluate the significance of those changes to the narrative as a whole. Is the character development consistent with the overall theme of the film?
j. Social and Cultural Context.
Consider the social and cultural context in which the characters exist. How does this context affect character development?
By following these steps, research into character development in a film can be more detailed and comprehensive.
This research methodology refers to character development theory which can also be linked to Roland Barthes' theory. This theory states that characters undergo archetypal journeys and transformations, responding to various challenges and internal conflicts. The Descriptive Qualitative Approach is justified for its ability to probe the nuances of Peter Parker's characterization, allowing for a thorough examination of the archetypal elements and psychological dimensions that contribute to his evolution across film adaptations.
3. Finding Result & Discussion.
The results of the research entitled "Peter Parker's Heroic Evolution : A Comparative Analysis of Peter Parker's Character Development in the Film Adaptation of Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004), and Spider-Man 3 (2007)" provide a comprehensive exploration . This research contains the development of Peter Parker's character in these iconic films. This section outlines the key findings and their implications, highlighting the importance of Peter Parker's character evolution within the broader context of the superhero genre and storytelling.
a. Evolution of Peter Parker's Character.
A comparative analysis of Peter Parker's character development in the film adaptations of "Spider-Man" (2002), "Spider-Man 2" (2004), and "Spider-Man 3" (2007) reveals the compelling evolution of his character. In these three films, Peter Parker undergoes a profound transformation from a shy and academic high school student to a confident and responsible superhero. This character development is foundational to the main narrative and is crucial in the continued appeal of the Spider-Man story.
Data obtained :
- Spider-Man (2002).
Evidence could include the moment where Peter first dons the Spider-Man costume and saves Mary Jane Watson from an armed criminal.
- Spider-Man 2 (2004).
Evidence could include the scene where Peter loses his powers and has to find his passion for being Spider-Man again.
- Spider-Man 3 (2007).
Evidence could include the part where Peter fights the dark nature influenced by the symbiote and eventually struggles to regain his goodness.
b. The Hero's Journey.
Peter Parker's character development closely follows the structure of the classic hero's journey, as outlined by Joseph Campbell. In each film, he embarks on a hero's journey, faces challenges, gains guidance from mentors, experiences personal growth, and finally undergoes a major transformation. His journey begins with the call of adventure, experiences trials and tribulations, deals with moral dilemmas, and finally fulfils his role as Spider-Man. The films effectively capture the essence of the hero's journey, making it a key element in the narrative and character development.
Data obtained :
- Spider-Man (2002).
Peter receives the "call of adventure" when he first tries out his new powers.
- Spider-Man 2 (2004).
Peter undergoes a series of tests, including the loss of his powers and a fight against Doctor Octopus.
- Spider-Man 3 (2007).
Peter is faced with a moral dilemma when he is influenced by the black costume and must face himself.
c. Internal and External Catalysts.
The research emphasizes the pivotal roles of both internal and external catalysts in molding Peter Parker's character throughout the Spider-Man film series. These catalysts play a crucial role in his transformation into a crime-fighting and morally responsible hero.
Data obtained :
- Spider-Man (2002).
In "Spider-Man" (2002), the death of Uncle Ben is a defining internal catalyst that propels Peter Parker into a life of crime-fighting and moral responsibility. This tragedy occurs when Peter fails to stop a thief who eventually robs and fatally shoots his beloved uncle. The pivotal scene where Peter confronts the thief showcases the consequences of his inaction and the pain of losing a father figure. This moment triggers a sense of guilt, responsibility, and a commitment to using his powers for the greater good, setting him on the path to becoming Spider-Man.
- Spider-Man 2 (2004).
Spider-Man 2 delves deeper into Peter's growth by introducing external catalysts. One of the external catalysts is the emergence of Doctor Octopus (Otto Octavius) as a formidable villain. A pivotal scene shows Peter confronting Doc Ock during a bank heist, highlighting the new challenges and threats he must face as a hero. Additionally, Peter's struggle to balance his dual identity is a recurring external catalyst. Scenes in the film depict his attempts to manage his responsibilities as Peter Parker and Spider-Man, including moments where he misses important events, like Mary Jane's play, due to his superhero duties.
- Spider-Man 3 (2007).
Spider-Man 3 continues to explore external catalysts with the introduction of new villains, most notably the Sandman and Venom. A crucial scene portrays Peter's confrontation with the Sandman in a construction site, illustrating the challenges he faces in dealing with multiple antagonists. The black suit, which enhances Peter's powers but also amplifies his aggression, represents an external catalyst that triggers a darker side of his personality. Scenes depict his struggle to control this newfound power, leading to moral dilemmas and internal conflict.
d. The Hero's Dilemma.
The hero's dilemma, a recurring theme in the Spider-Man narrative, is a significant aspect of Peter Parker's character development. The films highlight the challenges he faces in balancing his ordinary life, personal relationships, and academic aspirations with his responsibilities as Spider-Man. "Spider-Man 2" takes a deeper dive into this dilemma, vividly illustrating the sacrifices Peter must make for the greater good. This internal conflict adds profound depth to his character and resonates with audiences who can relate to the complexities of juggling multiple roles.
Data obtained :
- Spider-Man (2002).
The first Spider-Man film, we witness Peter's struggle to balance his newfound powers and responsibilities as a superhero with his ordinary life. A notable scene is when he ditches his high school field trip to engage in a wrestling match for quick cash. This choice represents the initial phase of his dual life, where he tries to fulfill personal needs alongside his growing responsibilities as Spider-Man.
- Spider-Man 2 (2004).
Spider-Man 2 explores the hero's dilemma extensively. A poignant example is the scene where Peter misses Mary Jane's play to confront Doctor Octopus. The moment captures the sacrifices he must make for the greater good, sacrificing his personal life for his duty as Spider-Man. This internal conflict becomes the emotional core of the film, highlighting the complexity of his choices.
- Spider-Man 3 (2007).
In "Spider-Man 3," Peter's internal conflict intensifies, mainly due to the influence of the symbiote suit. A scene that vividly portrays this dilemma is when Peter, under the suit's influence, confronts Sandman and becomes increasingly aggressive and ruthless. This illustrates the internal struggle within him as he grapples with the darker aspects of his personality.
e. Contribution to Spider-Man's Popularity.
This research underscores the enduring appeal of Spider-Man in popular culture and highlights the significance of storytelling in shaping this appeal. Peter Parker's character, as portrayed in the film adaptations, represents the quintessential "everyman," making his journey relatable to a wide audience. The character's evolution and the storytelling approaches used in the films have played a pivotal role in cementing Spider-Man's status as a beloved and iconic superhero.
Data obtained :
- Spider-Man (2002).
In the first Spider-Man film, there's a scene where Peter is struggling with typical teenage problems -- unrequited love, academic challenges, and fitting in. This relatable aspect of his character helps the audience connect with him on a personal level. The moment when he's bitten by the radioactive spider and begins to discover his powers represents the universal desire for change and empowerment, resonating with the audience.
- Spider-Man 2 (2004).
Spider-Man 2 dives deeper into Peter's personal struggles. A notable scene is when he's riding the subway without his powers and the passengers protect his secret identity. This scene exemplifies the film's focus on Peter's everyday life, humanizing him as someone who deals with typical problems and connects with ordinary people. It reinforces the idea that anyone can be a hero.
- Spider-Man 3 (2007).
In "Spider-Man 3," there's a scene where Peter is influenced by the symbiote suit, leading him to act in a more aggressive and self-serving manner. This scene illustrates the moral complexities within him, reflecting the internal struggles many people face. It shows that even heroes have flaws and grapple with ethical dilemmas. The enduring appeal of Spider-Man in popular culture is, in part, due to the character's relatability. Peter Parker's journey is one that many can connect with, as he faces challenges and dilemmas typical of everyday life. The storytelling in the films not only highlights his superhero adventures but also his personal growth, humanizing him and making his character development a central focus. This combination of relatability and storytelling has solidified Spider-Man's status as a beloved and iconic superhero, making him a timeless figure in the world of comics and cinema.
4. Conclusion.
The comprehensive exploration of Peter Parker's character development in the film adaptations of Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004), and Spider-Man 3 (2007) provides invaluable insights into the enduring popularity of this iconic superhero. Employing a descriptive qualitative approach, this research delves into the intricate interplay of personal struggles, moral dilemmas, and growth as a superhero, shedding light on the captivating evolution of Spider-Man. The evolution of Peter Parker's character arc, from a shy high school student to a confident and responsible superhero, is foundational to the Spider-Man narrative. Each film contributes significantly to this transformation, with pivotal moments such as Peter donning the Spider-Man costume, losing his powers, and grappling with the dark influence of the symbiote suit. These moments exemplify the character's profound journey and contribute to the continued allure of Spider-Man's story. The hero's journey, as outlined by Joseph Campbell, serves as a narrative backbone, guiding Peter through challenges, growth, and transformation. From the call of adventure in "Spider-Man" to the moral dilemma of the black costume in "Spider-Man 3," each film captures essential elements of the hero's journey, enriching both the narrative and character development.
Internal and external catalysts play crucial roles in shaping Peter Parker's character, emphasizing the impact of personal loss, formidable villains, and the struggle of dual identity. Uncle Ben's death acts as a defining internal catalyst, propelling Peter toward a life of crime-fighting and moral responsibility. External catalysts, including new villains and the black suit, introduce new challenges, illustrating the dynamic nature of his character development. The hero's dilemma, a recurrent theme, adds depth to Peter's character, highlighting the challenges of balancing ordinary life with superhero responsibilities. This internal conflict, vividly portrayed in moments such as Peter's balancing act in "Spider-Man" and his sacrifice in "Spider-Man 2," resonates with audiences, connecting them to the complexities of heroism. Contributing significantly to Spider-Man's enduring popularity is the relatability of Peter Parker as the quintessential "everyman." The films emphasize his personal struggles, making him a character with whom audiences can connect on a personal level. The universal desire for change and empowerment, depicted in scenes such as Peter's struggle on the subway in "Spider-Man 2," further enhances this relatability.
References.
[1] Â Sean Howe, Marvel Comics : The Untold Story, 2012. (Book)
[2] Â Joseph Campbell, The Hero with a Thousand Faces, 1949. (Book)
[3] Â Jeffrey A. Brown, Superhero Mythology : From Comic Books to Cinema, 2014. (Journal Articles)
[4] Â Linda Seger, The Art of Adaptation : Turning Fact and Fiction into Film, 2007. (Journal Articles)
[5] Â Jason Mittell, Narrative Complexity in Contemporary American Television, 2006. (Academic Papers)
[6] Â John W. Creswell, Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design : Choosing Among Five Approaches, 2012. (Academic Papers)
[7] Â Howard Suber, The Power of Film : Howard Suber on Making Movies, 2006. (Film Studies)
[8] Â David Bordwell and Kristin Thompson, Film Art : An Introduction, 2019. (Film Studies)
[9] Â Henry Jenkins, Textual Poachers : Television Fans and Participatory Culture, 1992. (Popular Culture Studies)
[10] Scott McCloud, Understanding Comics : The Invisible Art, 1993. (Popular Culture Studies)
[11] Muhammad Asri Devandi, Satyawati Surya, Anjar Dwi Astuti, Sociological Analysis on Peter Parker and Spiderman in the film Spiderman (2002). 2019. (Cultural Science Journal)
[12] Hidayatun Ni'mah, Dyah Kurniawati, The Representation of Masculinity through Peter Parker as the Main Character in Spider-Man No Way Home Movie. 2022. (Indonesian EFL Journal)
[13] Robert M, "With great power comes great responsibility" : Central psychoanalytic motifs in Spider-Man and Spider-Man 2, 2005. (Online Journal)
[14] Jon Bateman, "A One-In-A-Billion Chance A One-In-A-Billion Chance": The T ": The Transformativ ansformative Effect of Stan Lee ect of Stan Lee and Spider-Man on American Popular Culture, 2015. (Journal Articles)
[15] Scott Myers, Character Map, 2022. (Journal Articles)
Baca konten-konten menarik Kompasiana langsung dari smartphone kamu. Follow channel WhatsApp Kompasiana sekarang di sini: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaYjYaL4Spk7WflFYJ2H
